Guardianship and probate are both Florida court proceedings overseen by the same judges, but they solve opposite problems. Probate is how a court settles the affairs of someone who has died—paying debts and transferring assets to heirs. Guardianship is how a court protects someone who is still alive but can no longer make safe decisions about their person or property. The simplest way to keep them straight: probate is about the dead; guardianship is about the living.
In practice, families in Broward, Miami-Dade, and Palm Beach counties often run into both within the same family, sometimes within the same year. A parent loses capacity, the children open a guardianship, the parent later passes, and the same children turn around and open a probate. Because we handle a lot of real-property-heavy estates here in South Florida, we see the two collide most sharply when a homestead or a rental building is the family’s main asset. Below is how a Florida probate attorney actually distinguishes them, and what that means for your timeline, your costs, and the title to that house.
What is probate in Florida?
Probate is the court-supervised process of administering a deceased person’s estate. A personal representative (Florida’s term for what other states call an “executor”) is appointed, collects the decedent’s assets, gives notice to creditors, pays valid debts and taxes, and distributes whatever remains to the beneficiaries named in the will—or, if there is no will, to the heirs determined by Florida’s intestacy statutes.
The governing law is found in the Florida Probate Code, Chapters 731 through 735 of the Florida Statutes, with the procedural rules in the Florida Probate Rules. Florida recognizes two main paths:
- Formal administration (Fla. Stat. § 733) — the standard process for most estates, requiring a personal representative, letters of administration, and a creditor period.
- Summary administration (Fla. Stat. § 735.201) — available when the estate’s non-exempt assets are valued at $75,000 or less, or when the decedent has been dead for more than two years. No personal representative is appointed; the court enters an order distributing assets directly.
There is also a stripped-down option called disposition without administration for very small estates with no real property and only limited personal property. The key trigger for all of this is the same: a death certificate. No death, no probate.
Why probate matters so much for real property
Real estate is the reason probate cannot be skipped in many South Florida estates. If a house, condo, or rental property was titled solely in the decedent’s name—with no joint owner, no “ladybird” enhanced life estate deed, and no living trust holding title—then only a probate court can clear the chain of title so the property can be sold or transferred. A title company will not insure a sale until that order exists.
Florida’s homestead protections add another layer. The constitutional homestead, under Article X, Section 4 of the Florida Constitution, passes outside the normal probate estate to surviving spouses and lineal descendants and is shielded from most creditors. Getting a court order that confirms the homestead character of the property is frequently the whole point of the proceeding. If you want a deeper walkthrough of how that works, see our overview of Florida probate.
What is guardianship in Florida?
Guardianship is a legal relationship in which a court appoints one person (the guardian) to make decisions for another person (the ward) who has been found unable to make those decisions safely on their own. The controlling law is Chapter 744 of the Florida Statutes, the Florida Guardianship Law.
Crucially, guardianship begins with a finding of incapacity, not a death. Before a guardian can be appointed in a contested incapacity case, the court appoints a three-member examining committee to evaluate the alleged incapacitated person. The committee—typically including a physician or psychologist and other qualified professionals—reports back on which specific rights the person can and cannot exercise. The judge then enters an order spelling out exactly which rights are removed.
Florida recognizes several flavors of guardianship:
- Guardianship of the person — authority over medical care, residence, and personal welfare.
- Guardianship of the property — authority over finances, real estate, bank accounts, and investments.
- Plenary guardianship — broad authority over both person and property when the ward has lost essentially all decision-making rights.
- Limited guardianship — the court removes only the specific rights the person genuinely cannot handle, preserving the rest. Florida law favors the least-restrictive option.
- Guardian advocacy (Fla. Stat. § 393.12) — a simpler route for adults with developmental disabilities that does not require an adjudication of total incapacity.
- Guardianship of a minor — appointed when a child inherits property or receives a settlement, or when parents cannot serve.
The ongoing court oversight that surprises families
One thing that catches families off guard: a guardianship is not a one-and-done event. A guardian of the property must file an initial inventory and then an annual accounting with the court, while a guardian of the person files an annual guardianship plan describing the ward’s health and living situation. The court—and often an appointed attorney for the ward—keeps watching for the entire life of the guardianship. Selling the ward’s home usually requires a specific court order first. Probate, by contrast, is finite: it opens, it runs its course, and it closes.
Guardianship vs. probate: a side-by-side comparison
Here is how the two diverge on the points that matter most to families:
- Triggering event. Guardianship is triggered by living incapacity; probate is triggered by death.
- Who is protected. Guardianship protects a living ward and that ward’s rights; probate moves a deceased person’s assets to the next generation.
- Governing statute. Guardianship lives in Chapter 744 (and § 393 for guardian advocacy); probate lives in Chapters 731–735.
- Duration. Guardianship can last years, until the ward recovers capacity or dies. Probate is designed to end—often within roughly six months to a year for a straightforward formal administration.
- Court oversight. Guardianship requires recurring annual filings; probate requires a single round of accounting before closing.
- Effect on real estate. A guardian needs court permission to sell the ward’s property; a personal representative needs authority (from the will or a court order) to sell estate property and clear title.
They share DNA, too. Both are heard in the circuit court’s probate division. Both involve fiduciaries who answer to a judge. Both require bonds in many cases, formal notice to interested parties, and careful accounting. And in both, mistakes by the fiduciary can create personal liability—which is exactly why people retain counsel rather than navigating the dockets alone.
When a single family needs both
Consider a common South Florida scenario. An 84-year-old widow in Boca Raton develops advanced dementia. She owns her homestead free and clear and a small duplex she rents out. She never signed a durable power of attorney. Because no one has legal authority to manage her money or maintain her real estate, her son petitions for a guardianship of the property under Chapter 744. He is appointed, posts a bond, files an inventory, and—after getting a court order—uses rental income to pay her care.
Eighteen months later, she passes away. The guardianship ends automatically at death, and the guardian’s final job is to file a final accounting and turn the assets over to her estate. Now her son opens a probate under Chapter 733 as personal representative, because the homestead and the duplex were titled in her name alone. The same person wears two different legal hats, governed by two different chapters of the statutes, in two sequential proceedings.
The lesson families take from cases like this: both proceedings could have been narrowed or avoided with planning. A durable power of attorney could have prevented the guardianship of the property entirely. A revocable living trust, or even properly drafted deeds, could have kept the duplex and home out of probate. If you are setting up that foundation, start with sound wills and estate documents and talk to counsel about whether a trust fits your real-estate holdings.
How to avoid both guardianship and probate
You cannot always avoid these proceedings, but good documents dramatically shrink the odds. The most effective tools in Florida are:
- Durable power of attorney (Fla. Stat. Ch. 709). A properly executed, durable POA lets your chosen agent manage finances if you lose capacity—often eliminating the need for a guardianship of the property.
- Designation of health care surrogate (Fla. Stat. Ch. 765). This covers medical decisions and can head off a guardianship of the person.
- Revocable living trust. Assets titled in a funded trust avoid probate at death and can be managed by a successor trustee during incapacity—addressing both problems at once.
- Enhanced life estate (“lady bird”) deeds and joint titling. These can pass Florida real property directly to beneficiaries outside probate, while preserving homestead protections during life.
- Beneficiary and payable-on-death designations. Bank accounts, retirement plans, and life insurance pass by designation, not by probate.
The catch is that these tools must be signed while you still have capacity. Once a person is incapacitated, the only option left is guardianship—the very thing the documents were meant to prevent.
How a South Florida probate attorney helps
Both guardianship and probate are document-heavy, deadline-driven proceedings where a missed creditor notice or a defective accounting can cost the family money or expose the fiduciary to liability. An experienced attorney determines which proceeding you actually need (sometimes neither), prepares the petitions, manages notice to interested parties, and—critically for our real-property-heavy estates—obtains the court orders needed to sell or transfer a homestead or investment property with clean, insurable title.
Our firm’s Florida team handles these matters daily; you can learn more about our . For families with assets or relatives in New York as well, our affiliated New York office covers complementary issues such as and, when a will is challenged, —useful background even for Florida residents, since will contests can spill across state lines. To map out your own situation, contact our office for a consultation.
Frequently asked questions
Is guardianship the same as probate?
No. Guardianship protects a living person who can no longer make safe decisions, under Chapter 744 of the Florida Statutes. Probate settles a deceased person’s estate, under Chapters 731–735. They are heard in the same court division but serve opposite purposes.
Does a guardianship end when the ward dies?
Yes. A Florida guardianship terminates automatically upon the ward’s death. The guardian’s remaining duties are to file a final accounting and deliver the assets to the deceased ward’s estate, which is then administered through probate if probate is required.
Can you avoid both probate and guardianship in Florida?
Often, yes—if you plan ahead. A durable power of attorney and a health care surrogate designation can prevent guardianship, while a funded revocable living trust, beneficiary designations, and proper deeds can keep assets out of probate. These documents must be signed while you still have legal capacity.
Which court handles guardianship and probate in South Florida?
Both are handled by the probate division of the circuit court in the county where the person lived—for example, the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit in Broward, the Eleventh in Miami-Dade, and the Fifteenth in Palm Beach.
Do I need a lawyer for probate or guardianship in Florida?
In most formal probate administrations and contested guardianships, Florida law and court rules effectively require representation by an attorney, because the personal representative or guardian is acting in a fiduciary capacity for others. Even where it is not strictly required, the deadlines and liability exposure make counsel strongly advisable.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is guardianship the same as probate?
No. Guardianship protects a living person who can no longer make safe decisions, under Chapter 744 of the Florida Statutes. Probate settles a deceased person’s estate, under Chapters 731-735. They are heard in the same court division but serve opposite purposes.
Does a guardianship end when the ward dies?
Yes. A Florida guardianship terminates automatically upon the ward’s death. The guardian’s remaining duties are to file a final accounting and deliver the assets to the deceased ward’s estate, which is then administered through probate if probate is required.
Can you avoid both probate and guardianship in Florida?
Often, yes, if you plan ahead. A durable power of attorney and a health care surrogate designation can prevent guardianship, while a funded revocable living trust, beneficiary designations, and proper deeds can keep assets out of probate. These documents must be signed while you still have legal capacity.
Which court handles guardianship and probate in South Florida?
Both are handled by the probate division of the circuit court in the county where the person lived, for example the Seventeenth Judicial Circuit in Broward, the Eleventh in Miami-Dade, and the Fifteenth in Palm Beach.
Do I need a lawyer for probate or guardianship in Florida?
In most formal probate administrations and contested guardianships, Florida law and court rules effectively require representation by an attorney, because the personal representative or guardian is acting in a fiduciary capacity for others. Even where not strictly required, the deadlines and liability exposure make counsel strongly advisable.
Have a question about your estate?
Talk it through with Russel Morgan — free 30-minute consult.
